On November 24, 1860, the 27th anniversary of Psi Upsilon’s founding, the Iota Chapter was installed at Kenyon College in Gambier, Ohio. Apart from the Theta, the Iota is the only chapter with the unique privilege of sharing its founding date with Psi Upsilon itself. It was also the Fraternity’s first chapter outside New York and New England, and its founders spent two years and two Conventions achieving it.
Kenyon, founded in 1824 by Bishop Philander Chase, was by the late 1850s one of the leading colleges in the West, with about 125 students on its hill above the Kokosing River. On the evening of October 23, 1858, eight students met in the room of Erasmus Owen Simpson, Iota 1861, in the west wing of Old Kenyon. Simpson and Robert McNeilly, Iota 1860, had brought the group together with Psi Upsilon in mind. That night they signed a petition and sent it to the Beta Chapter at Yale.
The established fraternities at Kenyon opposed the new group and tried to lure away its members, but the petitioners had friends in the East, led by the Rev. Charles Cotton Salter, Beta 1852 (Yale). The 1859 Convention, held with the Lambda, declined the petition. A second petition failed at the 1860 Convention with the Zeta by just two votes, and the ten chapters in favor asked the two holdouts to reconsider that fall. In October, McNeilly, by then a graduate and still not a member, traveled east again on funds his brothers had raised “by privation and personal sacrifice.” According to tradition, the opposition finally came down to one man, who at last gave way.
McNeilly was initiated by the Theta at Union, bought eleven badges from the Fraternity jeweler, and arrived back in Gambier on November 23. The group agreed to wait one more day so that the Iota’s birthday would fall on Psi Upsilon’s own, though they could not resist wearing their new pins that morning. That evening McNeilly initiated his brothers in Major Riley’s parlor. He described the night in a letter of December 18, 1860:
We afterwards sang a number of Psi U songs, with great enthusiasm and then partook of the excellent supper prepared for the occasion… and after keeping it up till a late hour we separated highly delighted with the evening’s proceedings in general and with the strongest fraternal feeling toward “Old Psi U” in particular.
The eleven charter members went on to careers as physicians, lawyers, an Army officer and Episcopal clergymen. Among them was Henry Lambton Curtis, Iota 1862, whose father had first pointed out the Gambier site to Bishop Chase. Writing in January 1861, a Kenyon correspondent declared that the new charter showed Kenyon “stands at the head of western colleges.”

For its first thirty years, the Iota met in a rented loft over a wagoner’s shop that members fondly called the “Dear Old Spot.” In 1864 the young chapter voted to charter the petitioners at the University of Michigan and initiated their leader, John Barnes Root, Phi 1865 (Michigan), in Gambier. On January 26, 1865, Clifford Beakes Rossell, Iota 1865, installed the Phi Chapter at Ann Arbor. Twice, in 1882 and 1895, the Iota came down to a single returning brother. Roger Peters, Iota 1885, rebuilt the chapter with help from nearby alumni. Philemon Stanbery, Iota 1898, did the same alongside Frank Irving Cornwell, Phi 1898 (Michigan), who transferred from Michigan to help save the Phi’s mother chapter.

The Iota also gave Psi Upsilon some of its best-loved songs. Charles Drake McGuffey, Iota 1863, a son of the author of the famous McGuffey Readers, wrote “Convention Song,” “Our Gallant Band,” “Our Lodge-Room” and “The Origin of Psi Upsilon.” Charles Henry Arndt, Iota 1889, wrote “Welcome, Brothers, Old and Young” for the 1888 Convention, held with the Iota, and set it to the Civil War tune “Tramp, Tramp, Tramp.” By 1941 every one of the Fraternity’s 27 active chapters counted it among their songs, making it the most widely sung in Psi Upsilon.
Few brothers have served the Fraternity longer than Earl D. Babst, Iota-Phi 1893, who also joined the Phi while studying law at Michigan. He served on the Executive Council from 1908 to 1928 and was its President from 1924 to 1928, succeeding Herbert L. Bridgman, Gamma 1866 (Amherst). Babst was President and later Chairman of the American Sugar Refining Company and a longtime trustee of Kenyon, and the Psi Upsilon Foundation still awards an undergraduate scholarship in his name. Two other Iota men, Leo W. Wertheimer, Iota 1899, and Walter T. Collins, Iota 1903, also served on the Executive Council, Collins as its Treasurer.
Other sons of the Iota made their mark well beyond Gambier. James Kent Stone, Iota 1861, served as president of Kenyon and then of Hobart College. Augustus John Ricks, Iota 1865, became a federal judge in Ohio, and Oscar W. Newman, Iota 1888, a justice of the Supreme Court of Ohio. Guy Despard Goff, Iota 1888, represented West Virginia in the United States Senate. Colonel Harry C. Benson, Iota 1877, was superintendent of Yosemite and then Yellowstone National Parks, and the Rt. Rev. Charles Clingman, Iota 1905, became the Episcopal Bishop of Kentucky. More recently, Tommy Vietor, Iota 2002, served as national security spokesman for President Barack Obama and co-founded Crooked Media.
In 1937 Iota alumni built a stone lodge near the Kenyon campus, and the following spring Kenyon hosted the Fraternity’s 1938 Convention. The Convention returned to Gambier in 1974. Known simply as “The Lodge,” the building still stands. It is owned by the Iota Alumni Association, which recently renovated it.

The Iota has been inactive since 2010, but its story is not over. Psi Upsilon is in conversation with Kenyon College and Iota alumni about restarting the chapter, and we hope to have an Owl Club at Kenyon within the next year. The college has not yet made its decision, but when Kenyon is ready, Psi Upsilon will be too. If you would like to be involved in supporting a restart of the Iota Chapter, please contact Executive Director Thomas Fox, Omicron 2000 (Illinois), at tfox@psiu.org.
You can read more about the founding of the Iota, and its early life at Kenyon, in the Annals of Psi Upsilon on our online archives site.
We plan to highlight stories about our past on a regular basis to help promote our online digital archive collection as well as share important milestones in our fraternity’s storied history that may otherwise be overlooked. If you would be interested in helping us create content please contact our Director of Engagement Jonathan Chaffin, Gamma Tau ’00 at jonathan@psiu.org.

